What’s With All the Auction Shows?
I couldn’t help but notice unscripted shows about auctions. You have Auction Kings which premiered on October 26, 2010 on Discovery. Funny thing, only a day later, Syfy premiered Hollywood Treasure. And then there’s Auction Hunters that premiered on November 9, 2010 on Spike. That’s THREE auction series that premiered in only a few weeks time.
First, I want to apologize for not picking up on this sooner. I was aware of the Discovery and Syfy ones (since I watch those channels often), but just recently saw ratings notes for Spike’s one. This is what made me wonder what the deal is.
Next, in my quest, let me pick apart what the difference between these series are. Starting with Auction Kings, it revolves around one auction house, Gallery 63 in Atlanta. It’s rise came about after the success of History Channel’s Pawn Stars, which are similar when it comes to old antique items and them being appraised and sold. In this case, at an auction. I don’t watch either, but from what I gathered from, yes, Wikipedia, Auction Kings follows a similar format to that of Pawn Stars. There are experts to appraise items of historical significance and a multiple choice question (for some reason). Syfy’s Hollywood Treasure, goes a more fun route, it follows a California-based appraiser who looks for, well, Hollywood memorabilia, check authenticity of the items and auction them off. Spike’s Auction Hunters, which deals with storage-unit auctions (’cause, from what I hear (I saw it in a Criminal Minds episode, “Limelight”), if someone rents a storage unit and it’s neglected, they can legally auction off the units after I think 6 months or something?). Anyway, this being on Spike, it’s seems to focus more on finds of antique guns, baseball cards, and guitars.
So, the shows offer there different attributes to the table. A big history buff looks like they would enjoy Auction Kings on Discovery more (which doesn’t focus on specific types of items, so it may be more appealing in general), and a guns and ammo guy, would probably love watching Auction Hunters on Spike. And pop-culture and media buffs, especially sci-fi fanatics, would get a kick out of Syfy’s Hollywood Treasure.
Now, I can see the appeal, things like these can be very interesting. I just find it strange on how they all premiered within a month of each other. Then again, people in general get into things, love them for a year or two, so the popularity stays high, then they are phased out. One network does a competition reality show, and then all the others jump on board. But, most end up goner, while in the end, a few (like Survivor) well, survive. This idea of either people put into one place, and then one is voted out, was just a huge thing. It moves on to talent competition, having FOX bring in American Idol, other singing competitions follow, same goes for dancing. But in the end, only one still ends up being the bigger ratings powerhouse. And reality shows aren’t the only ones doing this. Scripted show fall victims to this as well. We have two shows where the lead is pretending to be a psychic, not to mention had two shows where the leads were actually psychics, all within the last five years. There’s been a slight bump on Moonlighting-esque crime dramas, and now it seems every show wants to do a musical episode.
Remember when court-room drama were the “it” thing? Law and Order lasted for 20 seasons, spawned four spin-offs (don’t forget, there was the failed Trial by Jury a few years back), but now, no one is watching them (Law and Order got canned last season, Criminal Intent, I think, has one season left, the new spin-off Los Angeles isn’t doing all that great, and SVU is still the more higher rated, but it’s not looking overly pretty, but still good in an NBC standpoint though. Plus, other courtroom shows, The Good Wife and The Defenders aren’t doing too great in ratings for CBS). Got two vampire shows in the US, one more on the way (which is the US remake of a British series, Being Human, I recommend the British series), mixed in a pool of vampire films (though, that seems to have died down a little, unless I haven’t heard anything, it seems to be existing franchises such as the most awesome of them, Underworld, but unfortunately, there’s still more of the horrible Twilight crap left that overshadows potentially good vampire films (such as Daybreakers, it wasn’t that bad), after that it was zombies (which I guess there’s still love for that, since The Walking Dead ended up being a big ratings win for AMC). Talking about films, let’s not forget the comic-to-movie surge, which is still going on, with a few big franchises, along with a few bad attempts).
I think the point is, the American TV/(and film) viewers seem to have a short attention span. The next big, what people call ‘fad’, will happen soon, and a whole slew of related projects will come about (maybe witches is the next thing, or there will be robot phase, and for TV, look for an increase in comedies, particularly romantic comedies, as TV.Com pointed out, there are five shows coming up in the midseason schedule, plus one on now, about couples in different stages of a relationship (such as one that are married, one that’s been together for years, and one that’s been going out for a couple of months)). Maybe one or two will live on another season, but I expect networks to keep trying as multiple-camera comedies tend to be as cheap as you can get for a scripted show. Afterall, both NBC and ABC are each having comedies go in the 10pm hour (ABC Wednesdays and NBC Thursdays are all comedy in the midseason).
Back to unscripted, I imagine there being a few more auction-related series, then a new thing will emerge. All it takes is one network to have success with a new (or semi-new) idea and then others will follow.


